New York State Chess Association Congress, Buffalo 1901

Pillsbury scores 9 out of 10 at the New York State congress
12 – 17 August 1901 · Buffalo, New York, United States
Pillsbury won with 9, ahead of Delmar and Napier 6½, Howell 4½, Marshall 2½ and Karpinski 1.
Incomplete record·29 of 30 games archived

Incomplete record. This archive holds 29 of the 30 games played; 1 is missing.

The masters' tournament of the New York State Chess Association's congress was a six-player double round robin held in Buffalo in August 1901. Harry Nelson Pillsbury won with 9 points out of 10, two and a half points ahead of Eugene Delmar and William Ewart Napier.

The congress and the field

The tournament was played at the New York State Chess Association's congress in Buffalo. Six players met each other twice over ten rounds: Pillsbury, Delmar, Napier, Clarence Howell, Frank Marshall and Louis Karpinski. The congress ended a few weeks before President William McKinley was assassinated in Buffalo.

During the tournament Pillsbury also gave a blindfold exhibition against sixteen opponents at once, a display that John S. Hilbert's book on the congress records in an appendix.

Pillsbury far ahead

Pillsbury finished on 9 points. Delmar and Napier tied for second with 6½, Howell was fourth on 4½, Marshall fifth on 2½, and Karpinski last on 1. In Hilbert's account Pillsbury's endgame play was what set him apart from the rest of the field.

Napier annotated some of the games. Of Marshall's willingness to give up a pawn and try to win it back, he remarked that the idea was out of keeping with sound chess.

Twenty-nine of the thirty games have been published. The missing game is Marshall against Karpinski in round 9. Some references describe Marshall's second win over Karpinski as a forfeit, while Hilbert did not find the game but found evidence that it was played.

“the idea of giving up a pawn and struggling to regain it is not compatible with accepted notions of sound chess”
— William Ewart Napier, quoted in Paul Kane's review of John S. Hilbert, The New York State Chess Association Congresses – Buffalo 1894 and 1901 (2009)

Result

9/10
Pillsbury won with 9, ahead of Delmar and Napier 6½, Howell 4½, Marshall 2½ and Karpinski 1.

The archive holds 29 of 30 games; Marshall-Karpinski (round 9) was never traced.