Printed Game No. 24, pp. 31–33 (PDF pp. 83–85). The source identifies the first round and dates the game March 30, 1889. Original analytical move numbers are retained, including “26 B—K3 ch.” in note (h).

1. 5.d4 We prefer in this position the development by P—Q3 and P—QB3.
2. 11.dxe7 This move gives White the superior development, whereas 11 B x Kt, 11 KtxP leaves the game even.
3. 12.Bf4 P—QB3 was preferable.
4. 14.cxb3 White gives the opponent command with his Knight in the centre, but obviously he had nothing better, for if RPx Kt, Black would win a Pawn after the exchange of Queens.
5. 20…f6 P—KB4 at once would have gained time.
6. 30.Kg3 An adventurous movement of White's King that only causes him loss of time.
7. 34.h4 An excellent resource for drawing purposes if he had only played properly afterward.
8. 36.Kg1 26 B—K3 ch. was the right move that equalized the game without much trouble, for if Black moved the King, then the White King could safely enter at R3, and if 36...KtxB; 37RxKt, 37K—Kt4; 38 P—B3, 38 K—B5; 39 RxP ch., and draws.
9. 40.fxe4+ The exchange of Pawns was injudicious. K—B2, followed by the exchange of Rooks and afterward KxP, in case Black exchanged Pawns, made a draw more probable, and White could expect no more.
10. 41…Nf4 Excellent play. Black does not allow the opponent to take possession of the upper row with his Rook.
11. 46.a4 At this point Mr. Judd claimed a fifty moves count.
12. 47…a5 Black impetuously throws away a sure win in a short number of moves. He could easily gain the opposition and throw the onus of moving on the opponent by 47...K—B5; 48 K—R3, 48 K—Kt4; 49 K—R2, 49 K—Kt5. White's Pawn moves on the other wing could then be easily exhausted, and Black's King would gain entrance at Kt 6, followed by P—KR6, winning easily.
13. 49.b4 Black had evidently overlooked this fine answer.
14. 53…Qb5 Q—KKt 3 was, we believe, better adapted to keep everything safe and to lead the King over to the Q side without his being subjected to many checking troubles.
15. 57.Qg7+ Again Q—Q8 ch. was better.
16. 61.Qe1+ Simply capturing the RP that hampered the advance of his King gave him much better prospects of drawing, as Black's QBP could not advance far without giving White again many checking opportunities that would have impeded its progress.
17. 63.Qe3+ As a rule in such positions, the closer to the adverse King the checks are given the more effective they are. Q—B3 ch. was the right play, and whatever Black might do either the checks would continue or the adverse Queen could only interpose in a manner that left his QBP unprotected, which gave additional chances of a draw for White.
18. 74…Kc2 If Black exchange Queens, he can only effect a draw.
19. 96…Qc3 Mr. Judd stated afterward that he played the greater part of this ending in reliance on his having the legal right of claiming a draw if he could only extend the game to fifty moves after he had claimed the count without being mated. Having accomplished his object he refused to go on with the game, which he might have done under protest without damaging his rights. But his interpretation of the rule was not sustained on appeal, and Mr. Judd was also adjudged to have forfeited the game on the ground that he did not abide by the decision of the umpire to proceed with the same.